This Recording

In Which Jose Gonzalez Teaches Us The Meaning Of Saudade by Molly Lambert
August 24, 2007, 10:16 am
Filed under: Uncategorized

by Molly Lambert


An attempt to depict saudade through clip art

Saudade is a Portuguese and Galician word meaning a feeling of longing for something that one is fond of, which is gone, but might return in a distant future. It has a fatalist tone and involves repressed knowledge that the object of longing might really never return.

There’s no direct English translation. It’s apparently very difficult to translate, because the translation depends completely on context. The German word Sehnsucht has a similar meaning and reputation for untranslatibility. There’s also a Japanese cousin, mono no aware, which means a gentle sadness at being aware of the transience of things and their passing.

Jose Gonzalez wears his heart on his heart

My brother hipped me to Jose Gonzalez, the Swedish-born Argentinian singer-songwriter. His cover of The Knife’s “Heartbeats” is killer. Ian showed me the attendant beautiful video by Andreas Nilsson where a million bouncy balls are filmed coming down a steep San Francisco hill. It’s like a CGI effect done without computers.

Sometimes even I am the last to know about things. Gonzalez’s‘s voice sounds like the great Gilbert O’Sullivan song “Alone Again, Naturally” (not to be confused with Love’s “Alone Again Or” though I guess they all cover similarly bittersweet territory).


The Argentine Beatles, Los Shakers

What it really sounds like (other than Nick Drake) is Tropicalia, which is Brazillian, not Argentine. Most specifically Caetano Veloso and Jorge Ben.

jorge Ben

What’s up, 1969?

Wiki says:

Saudade is different than nostalgia (the English word, that is). In nostalgia, one has a mixed happy and sad feeling, a memory of happiness but a sadness for its impossible return and sole existence in the past. Saudade is like nostalgia but with the hope that what is being longed for might return, even if that return is unlikely or so distant in the future to be almost of no consequence to the present. One might make a strong analogy with nostalgia as a feeling one has for a loved one who has died and saudade as a feeling one has for a loved one who has disappeared or is simply currently absent.

Nostalgia is located in the past and is somewhat conformist while saudade is very present, anguishing, anxious and extends into the future. In Portuguese, the same word nostalgia has quite a different meaning. Although it relates to feelings of melancholy and fond memories of things/people/days gone by, it can be a rush of sadness coupled with a paradoxical joy derived from acceptance of fate and the hope of recovering or substituting what is lost by something that will either fill in the void or provide consolation.


“Some specialists say the word may have originated during the Great Portuguese Discoveries, giving meaning to the sadness felt about those who departed on journeys to unknown seas and disappeared in shipwrecks, died in battle, or simply never returned. Those who stayed behind—mostly women and children—suffered deeply in their absence;


The state of mind has subsequently become a “Portuguese way of life”: a constant feeling of absence, the sadness of something that’s missing, wishful longing for completeness or wholeness and the yearning for the return of that now gone, a desire for presence as opposed to absence—as it is said in Portuguese, a strong desire to “matar as saudades” (lit. to kill the saudades).


The same feeling is also found in Brazil, the destination of immigrants who never saw their homelands again. The feeling was so much ingrained into the Brazilian mind that virtually every immigrant settled there learned this notion and incorporated it (even people from radically different mindsets, like Germans and Japanese, soon understood it). Another permanent source of saudades for the Brazilians is the hugeness of the country itself, which in the past caused most people to feel alone almost everywhere.”

Andreas Nilsson’s video for Jose Gonzalez’s “Down The Line”

A UK Art exhibition about saudade

Jose Gonzalez MySpace

Jose Gonzalez video for “Crosses”

Jose Gonzalez video for “Heartbeats” (The Knife cover)

The Knife’s video for “Heartbeats”

Jose Gonzalez – Slow Moves: mp3

Jose Gonzalez – Heartbeats: mp3

Jose Gonzalez – Hints: mp3

Molly Lambert is Senior Editor of This Recording. Like Don Draper, she can be kind of a gloomy Jew.

About these ads

15 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Jose Gonzalez is the Adam Duritz of the chattering class.

That’s my new name for our generation, the chattering class, what do you think?

Comment by alexcarnevale

wow- you couldn’t have described jose’s music more spot on. you get it. there is something so painfully beautiful in his music and simple yet intimate.

Comment by audiotaco

[...] said. “I don’t know what the factors will be, but I believe it will happen.” He didn’t look like he wholly believed it would. As though to reassure himself, he added, “We actually talked about doing something not long [...]

Pingback by In Which We Have Not Lost Our Determination To Remain Owen Wilson « This Recording

[...] else see Conan the other night when Jose Gonzalez was on? There was a skit where the Philly Phanatic shot Mr. Met? Prettaaaay prettaaaay [...]

Pingback by In Which We Meet The Mets Poet « This Recording

[...] melancholy. Speaking of autumnal melancholy, related intimately as it is to Fado and Saudade, Jose Gonzalez is playing in L.A. on Wednesday. If you’re lucky enough to have tickets you should uh, give [...]

Pingback by In Which It’s All Part Of My Autumn Almanac « This Recording

[...] Comments In Which It’s … on In Which Jose Gonzalez Teaches…RandomReader on In Which I Bowed To My Brother…redink on Contributor-At-Large Will [...]

Pingback by In Which We Examine The Anatomy Of Charlie Brown’s Melancholy « This Recording

[...] suffered the usual isolation intrinsic to junior high. I hit puberty on the early side, but I was short and young-looking. I [...]

Pingback by In Which Adolescence Claims A Fast Talking Victim of Circumstance « This Recording

[...] x. Veronika Voss : The original title of this Rainer Werner Fassbinder film is Die Sehnsucht Der Veronika Voss. Sensucht is the German version of saudade. [...]

Pingback by In Which We Curate The Criterion Collection For Your Pleasure « This Recording

[...] Jose Gonzalez and Saudade [...]

Pingback by In Which Our Favorites Pick Their Favorites « This Recording

Jose Gonzales

there is this post i just read about Jose that really resonated with me. I think you should read it.
Author Molly Lambert compares Jose’s music to the term Saudade and couldn’t be more accurate.
You should also watch this commercial feat. J…

Trackback by Take a bite out of the audio taco!

[...] x. Veronika Voss : The original title of this Rainer Werner Fassbinder film is Die Sehnsucht Der Veronika Voss. Sensucht is the German version of saudade. [...]

Pingback by In Which This Is So You Know What To Buy Me For My Birthday « This Recording

[...] Ana Beatriz Barros Ana Hickmann Ana Ivanovi Ana Paula Lemes Ananda Lewis [...]

Pingback by Justin Bieber ‘Has His Head On Straight’ | MotorSport News

[...] Diora Baird Dita Von Teese Dominique Swain Donna Feldman Drea de Matteo [...]

Pingback by Afternoon Links With Amy Winehouse | Dudettes Read Here Afternoon Links With Amy Winehouse | Get your daily fix here

hello there and thank you for your info – I have definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise some technical points using this site, as I experienced to reload the site many times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your hosting is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Well I am adding this RSS to my email and can look out for much more of your respective intriguing content. Ensure that you update this again soon..

Comment by Arie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 80 other followers

%d bloggers like this: