This Recording

In Which We Intend To Create a Parallel America Where Our Mothers Can Be President by alexcarnevale
February 18, 2008, 12:50 pm
Filed under: Uncategorized


Moms Are Awesome

by Alex Carnevale

A closely contested Democratic nomination has come down to a precious few states, and Hillary Clinton is about to be on the outside looking in.

In what was a series of desperation moves this month, Hillary fired her longtime friend and strategist Patti Solis Doyle in favor of Maggie Williams , she met with John Edwards and openly said she’d give him a prominent post in her administration, and she found herself weeping again.

“Run” – Air (mp3)


If Hillary has an eye towards running again, she’ll be facing a far more difficult challenge than the biggest rising star in world politics. She will herself be 68 after two terms of Barack, probably too old to mount a campaign if health concerns are dogging this one.

If Hillary could go back in time, she probably would. Her leadership on an overwrought and poorly conceived health care proposal hasn’t really hurt her during this campaign season, but it should have. Her oft-quoted statement about the campaign being over by February 5th hurts badly now, and shows how her people thought this race would go.

As several people have put it, if running a large-scale campaign is a meaningful test of managerial ability, then only Obama’s passed it. Both the Clinton and McCain campaigns have, at one point, run entirely out of money. But that’s not Hillary’s problem.

She’s not an inspirational person, and as someone put it to me yesterday, “Black people in America are in need of a lot more inspiration than women in America.” Unfair? Perhaps, but probably true. When it comes to inspiring identity politics, Clinton seems to be the candidate of choice. When it comes to inspiring the rest of us to take our clothes off, Obama gets it done.


“Fleur de Lis” – Cue (mp3)

“Quitter vs Feel So Sad (DJ Obama remix)” – Eminem feat. Spiritualized (mp3)

Despite some of the things I have written in this space, I like Hillary Clinton, certainly more than I do her asshole of a husband. Not everyone is destined for the presidency. It is a wearying and difficult job, and I don’t think there is really any way of preparing yourself.

Would a Hillary transition be easier? Of course, but a good manager is a good manager, and Obama has the advantage of not owing a bedroom to every Turkish anti-semite to donate to his campaign. Then again, Hillary does have Ugly Betty.


There is an overpowering sense that this is the Democrats’ election to lose. As George Stephanopoulus noted recently, the recession party has never won in American politics.

Last time the Democrats had power they faced a revitalized and charismatic conversative moment epitomized by Newt Gingrich’s Contract with America. The intense nature of the Clinton hatred led to gridlock, and there is nothing the American people like less than the appearance of inaction, even when it may be the proper course.


I think the great mistake of the Hillary campaign was in thinking that they had to warm her up. She’s a cold confident leader, that much we already divest from a moment with her. But the idea that her entire being is calculated is unshakable. They might have ran with that. Her sad statement this week that if this were a job interview, she’d be the top candidate may have been a campaign misstep, but at least it’s a theme.

To really stop Obama now, she has to make the case for herself.

Alex Carnevale is the editor of This Recording.



Josh Green’s classic piece about the gory insides of the Clinton campaign

Democrats don’t care when blacks are deprived of the vote

America’s three worst presidents

Talking Points Memo on Republicans educating their own about how to attack Barack

Obama talks to Edwards

This kinda says it all:


Real Clear Politics is the best

Bill gives Obama supporter a facial

The Corner is the best political blog there is


Sports Illustrated swimsuit mixtape.

Emily Haines and the hard turtle exoskeleton.

A private dictatorship of TMNT.


About these ads

8 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Seems we are on the same wavelength this morning…again.

Comment by folkrockgirl

This is a great post. The photo of the little girl on the stairs is kind of heartbreaking.

Comment by Lisa V

god I am going to murder those white dudes in the last pic.

Comment by Molly Lambert

[...] In Which We Intend To Create a Parallel America Where Our Mothers Can Be President [...]

Pingback by In Which We’re Here To Spit Semiotic Theory And Chew Bubblegum, And We’re All Out Of Bubblegum « This Recording

[...] your phone rang you got to hear the gently badgering voice of the woman who reminds you so much of your mother you’re scared to vote for her. What are you, worried the nation will turn out as fucked up as you are? Text [...]

Pingback by In Which Scarlett And Natalie Are Both The Other Woman « This Recording

[...] Most of them with integral, but less visible positions. What I have learned is that some people are repulsed by an outwardly ambitious woman. The hatred directed at Diablo has been mostly about her character and appearance, even when [...]

Pingback by In Which We Defend Diablo Cody « This Recording

[...] Some of my favorite pictures from the now defunct Hillary Clinton campaign. [...]

Pingback by In Which We Are A New Voting Bloc of Photosexuals « This Recording

[...] we first proclaimed Hillary dead, she’s been spinning in her grave just fast enough to become one of the best runner-ups in [...]

Pingback by In Which You Guys These Are Like The Best Links or Something « This Recording

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 80 other followers

%d bloggers like this: